Two new live-streaming apps were the talk of SXSW this year -- Meerkat and Periscope. Both offer users the ability to share live video content to Twitter in real time. So, which should you use?
I put them both to test in a "fight of the features" to find out which takes the title of best live stream app. Here's how they stacked up:
How They're Alike
Both apps give users the ability to stream live video content in real time. Both are integrated with Twitter, so when you begin broadcasting a stream, a link to it is instantly tweeted to your followers through your Twitter account. You can also save streams locally to your phone.
Within both apps, users can watch streams and simultaneously chat, identified by their Twitter handles, with each other and with the broadcaster. They can also follow other users and get notifications when they begin streaming.
What Makes Periscope Different
Periscope's interface is clean and intuitive. I found it to be much more user-friendly than the Meerkat interface, which feels somewhat cluttered and confusing. Periscope features a simple navigation bar at the bottom of the screen to divide up its core functions - streaming, followers/connections, and the feed.
The app also provides a helpful tutorial when you first open the app, which you can skip if desired, with a few key points about the its functionality. After the tutorial, the app guides you to a page of recommended users to follow (unlike Meerkat, you're pretty much on your own to find connections).
Unlike Meerkat where everything is live and there are no reruns, Periscope allows users to replay recent streams in a "Recent" section of the stream feed.
Downsides of Periscope:
As of now, you cannot schedule future streams, however, I expect they will probably add this soon. The stream feed is also less visual, and there are no gamification features (which you could consider bonuses or downsides, depending on your preference).
What Makes Meerkat Different
The biggest added bonus with Meerkat, in my opinion, is the ability to schedule future streams. Users can upload a photo and some text along with a scheduled time, and their followers will then get a push notification when the stream goes live. Also, if you schedule a stream and forget to go back in and start it, Meerkat will send a push notification reminding you that you're viewers are waiting for the scheduled stream.
I also appreciated the more visual feed of current live streams, with large images or stills from the stream video that give an idea of content. Stream previews in Meerkat also show a lot of information about the stream's current following, including number of current viewers, how many likes it has, and how many comments have been made in live Twitter chat taking place within the stream.
Finally, Meerkat includes some gamification features including a score that is always listed in the top left corner of the home screen, and a leaderboard. However, it is unclear to me how these points are accrued and how this works, and I was unable to find clarification within the app.
Downsides of Meerkat:
The main weakness of Meerkat is its interface. I believe it is not as user-friendly as it could be, and I imagine many first time users become frustrated or confused when they first open the app. The home screen feels cluttered, making it difficult for users to know where to go. On top of that, there is little to no guidance within the app that explains how it works or how to get started.
Have you used Meerkat or Periscope? Comment and tell me what you think of these new live-streaming apps!